Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I personally own and use.
For two years, VR fitness has been part of my daily routine. I am 50 years old, I work from home, and I needed something that gave me energy, structure, and real physical results without destroying my joints.
That app was Supernatural.
But with Supernatural now in maintenance mode and my subscription expiring next year, I had to prepare for the possibility that it might fully shut down. I did not want to be caught scrambling for alternatives at the last minute.
So I tested the Best Supernatural alternative and two serious contenders: FitXR and FunFitLand.
My focus was simple: Which VR fitness app can realistically replace what I built over the last two years?
What Matters Most to Me in a VR Fitness App
At this stage of life, my goal is not extreme muscle gain. I want consistent energy, core strength, balance, and visible tone. I also need something efficient. Most of my workouts are 15 to 20 minutes before starting my workday.
Boxing is my foundation. It keeps me sharp and engaged.
I also care about sustainability. High-impact workouts create repeated ground force through the knees and hips. In VR boxing, you are generating force into open space. There is no external load pushing back into your joints. That reduces compressive stress while still allowing your heart rate to climb. For me, that balance between effort and joint protection is critical.
How I Tested Each App: best Supernatural Alternative
I completed the 14-day trial of FunFitLand and tried all three of its modes: Combat Fit, Groove Fit, and Flow Fit.
Then I went through all seven FitXR modes, including Boxing, Combat, Sculpt, Dance, Zumba, HIIT, and Warm Up.
I evaluated each app based on:
- Boxing quality
- Music experience
- Intensity
- Coaching
- Variety
- Visual immersion
- Overall motivation
I paid attention to how my body felt during sessions and how motivated I felt coming back the next day.
Boxing Performance: The Core Test
If an app cannot deliver strong boxing mechanics, it is not replacing Supernatural for me.
Supernatural still leads. The pacing feels modern and precise. Target placement flows naturally, and sessions feel professionally structured. [LINK TO SUPERNATURAL REVIEW]
FunFitLand’s Combat Fit works mechanically. You will move and sweat. But it feels more playful than performance-driven. That may appeal to some users, but it does not push me the same way. [LINK TO FUNFITLAND REVIEW]
FitXR’s Boxing mode is strong. It introduces additional movements that add variety and coordination. If I had never experienced Supernatural, I would likely rank it number one. But side by side, Supernatural still feels more refined. [LINK TO FITXR REVIEW]
Winner: Supernatural
Music: The Motivation Multiplier
Music determines how hard you push.
There is strong evidence that rhythmic auditory stimulation increases movement efficiency and perceived effort tolerance. In simple terms, good music makes hard work feel easier.
Supernatural uses licensed tracks and curated playlists that feel intentional and powerful.
FitXR and FunFitLand rely more on generic soundtracks. They function well, but they do not create the same emotional surge.
For long-term consistency, that difference matters.
Winner: Supernatural
Intensity Ranking
- Supernatural (Highest intensity)
- FitXR (Close second, especially with Sculpt mode)
- FunFitLand (Moderate intensity)
Supernatural offers clear intensity tiers, including a Pro level that elevates heart rate quickly.
FitXR surprised me, especially with Sculpt mode. By using controllers as counterweights, it increases muscular tension in the shoulders and arms. Even light resistance changes muscle fiber recruitment and adds a strength component.
FunFitLand can generate intensity, but it feels less structured toward progression.
Winner: Supernatural, with FitXR as strong second
Variety and Training Options
FitXR clearly dominates in variety. Seven workout categories create a full gym environment in VR. If you enjoy switching training styles, this is a major advantage.
FunFitLand keeps it simple with three core modes.
Supernatural remains focused on Boxing and Flow. That narrower focus may actually benefit users who prefer depth over breadth.
More options do not automatically equal better results. Clarity often improves adherence.
Winner: FitXR (for variety), Supernatural (for focused depth)
Coaching Quality
Supernatural’s coaches feel present and motivating. Their tone, pacing, and personality carried me through two years of consistent training.
FunFitLand uses real coaches. They are clear and informative.
FitXR mixes real instructors and 3D characters. I personally connect more with real human presence, but that is subjective.
Motivation style is personal. Some users prefer high energy. Others prefer calm direction.
Winner: Supernatural (for emotional connection)
Visual Environments
Supernatural creates a sense of scale and immersion that stands out immediately. Training in dramatic global environments adds emotional weight to the workout.
FunFitLand feels more like a playful training arena.
FitXR presents a clean gym-style environment.
Immersion does not directly change calorie burn, but it does influence engagement. When your attention is absorbed, perceived time decreases. That makes sessions feel shorter and easier to repeat.
Winner: Supernatural (for immersion)
Weight Management and Muscle Tone
From a physiological standpoint, fat loss comes from sustained caloric expenditure combined with consistency. All three apps can elevate heart rate into moderate to vigorous zones.
Over two years with Supernatural, I maintained my weight and reduced abdominal fat. I also developed visible tone in my arms and shoulders.
Muscle tone in VR boxing comes from repeated contractions under speed. Hundreds of punches create metabolic fatigue in the upper body. Over time, this improves definition even without heavy weights.
FitXR Sculpt enhances that effect by introducing additional resistance stimulus.
Winner: Tie (Supernatural for boxing tone, FitXR for added strength training)
VR Fitness Over 50: Safety and Brain Benefits
One underrated benefit of VR workouts is cognitive engagement.
You are reacting to moving targets, timing strikes to music, and shifting weight dynamically. That challenges coordination, reaction speed, and motor planning. Movement-based cognitive tasks stimulate neuroplasticity, which becomes increasingly important with age.
From a joint perspective, the absence of heavy external loads reduces compressive forces compared to barbell training or road running. That makes VR workouts a practical option for many adults over 50 who want intensity without high joint stress.
As always, proper form and a clear play space matter. [LINK TO VR FITNESS FOR 50+ ARTICLE]
Winner: All three (low-impact, high cognitive engagement)
Best App by Use Case
Best for Serious Boxing: Supernatural
Best for Full Gym Variety: FitXR
Best for Casual and Playful Workouts: FunFitLand
Best for Building Muscle Tone: FitXR Sculpt
Best for Long-Term Motivation: Supernatural
Best for Quick Sessions: All three offer efficient 10-30 minute workouts
Pricing Snapshot
Supernatural VR
• $9.99 USD/month ≈ $13.60 CAD/month
• $99.99 USD/year ≈ $136 CAD/year
FitXR
• $12.99 USD/month ≈ $17.65 CAD/month
• $107.99 USD/year ≈ $147 CAD/year
FunFitLand
• $9.99 USD/month ≈ $13.60 CAD/month
• $99.99 USD/year ≈ $136 CAD/year
Always confirm current pricing on official websites.
Final Verdict
If I could only choose one based purely on experience and quality, I would still choose Supernatural. It feels complete, focused, and performance-driven.
If Supernatural fully shuts down, FitXR is my immediate backup. Sculpt impressed me, and the range of training modes gives it long-term potential.
FunFitLand has value, especially for users who prefer a lighter atmosphere.
The most important factor is not the app. It is consistency. The body adapts to repeated effort. Show up regularly and progress follows.
Will the Beaver’s Opinion
Will looks at this scientifically. He respects structured progression, controlled joint loading, and cardiovascular conditioning without excessive impact. So yes, he leans toward Supernatural.
But even he admits FitXR is building a strong foundation.
He says the key is simple: Pick one. Commit. And keep building.
What I Use for All Three Apps
Whether using Supernatural, FitXR, or FunFitLand, the equipment setup is the same. Consistency matters more than which app you choose.
Quest 2 / Quest 3 – Works with both Supernatural and Funfitland
Its pretty close to what I have
15lb Kettlebell – Warm-up before, follow my workout routine
Its pretty close to what I have
Microfiber Cloth – Essential after serious sweat sessions
VR Head Strap – Comfort matters during 30+ minute workouts
Floor Fan – Prevents fogging on the lenses
KIWI GRIPS – these are my best investment